Kuus juhtivat kriitikut on valinud igaüks aasta parimad 10 filmi. Tulemused näitavad, et enim eelistatakse siiski reaalsust. Mitte ükski 2006. aasta film ei jõudnud ei jõudnud kõikidesse listidesse. Kuid "United 93" pääsest kokku viite. Tõesti, reaalsust hinnati väga, sest mitmed filmid põhinesid ajalool - iidsel, kui ka hiljutistel sündmustel. Peale "Unitedi" ja "The Queen", Clint Eastwoodi kaks Iwo Jima filmi jne.

Kirk Honeycutt:
1. Flags of Our Fathers
2. Letters From Iwo Jima
3. "Happy Feet"
4. "United 93"
5. "The Queen"
6. "The Lives of Others"
7. "Children of Men"
8. "Volver"
9. "Pan's Labyrinth"
10. "Borat"

Sheri Linden
1. "The Death of Mr. Lazrescu"
2. "United 93"
3. "The Queen"
4. "Army of Shadows"
5. "Half Nelson"
6. "Tristam Shandy: A Cock and Bull Story"
7. "La Moustache"
8. "Infamous"
9. "Duck Season"
10. "Marie Antoinette"

Michael Rechtshaffen
1. "United 93"
2. "The Queen"
3. "Babel"
4. "An Inconvenient Truth"
5. "Letters From Iwo Jima"
6. "Borat"
7. "Little Miss Sunshine"
8. "Who Killed the Electric Car?"
9. "The Departed"
10. "Dreamgirls"

Richard James Havis
1. "V for Vendetta"
2. "The Departed"
3. "Pan's Labyrinth"
4. "The Road to Guantanamo"
5. "Curse of the Golden Flower"
6. "Inland Empire"
7. "Army of Shadows"
8. "Iron Island"
9. "Lunacy"
10. "The Proposition"

Ray Bennett
1. "Babel"
2. "Children of Men"
3. "Pan's Labyrinth"
4. "Volver"
5. "Flags of Our Fathers"
6. "The History Boys"
7. "Little Miss Sunshine"
8. "United 93"
9. "Apocalypto"
10. "Dreamgirls"

Frank Scheck
1. "The Queen"
2. "Letters From Iwo Jima"
3. "The Departed"
4. "Babel"
5. "United 93"
6. "Little Children"
7. "Dreamgirls"
8. "Borat"
9. "The Death of Mr. Lazarescu"
10. "An Inconvenient Truth"

Toimetas: Robert
4. jaanuar 2007, kell 20:30